Four Kinds of Dystopia

welcome_to_dystopia_by_crystalryu

By Darren Allen

Source: ExpressiveEgg.org

The twentieth century saw four basic visions of hell on earth, or dystopia. These were:

Orwellian. Rule by autocratic totalitarian people, party or elite group, limitation of choice, repression of speech and repression of minorities, belief in order, routine and rational-morality. Control by enclosure, fear and explicit violence. Violent repression of dissent (via ‘the party line’). Erotic physicality and sexual freedom suppressed via control of sexual impulses. Control of thought by explicitly policing language (Orwellian Newspeak).

Huxleyan Rule by democratic totalitarian systems, excess of choice, limitation of access to speech platforms, assimilation of minorities, belief in emotional-morality, ‘imagination’ and flexibility, and control by desire, debt and implicit threat of violence. No overt control of dissent (system selects for system-friendly voices). Erotic physicality and sexual freedom suppressed via promotion of pornographic sensuality and dissolution. Control of thought by implicitly enclosing language within professional boundaries (Illichian Newspeak, or Uniquack).

Kafkaesque Rule by bureaucracy. Control of populace via putting them into writing, forcing people to spend free time on bureaucratic tasks, thereby inducing tractable stress and the schizoid, self-regulating self-consciousness (anxiety about low marks, unlikes, official judgements and the like) that bureaucratic surveillance engenders. Generation of a system which structurally rewards those who seek an indirect relationship with their fellows or who, through fear of life, seek to control it through the flow of paperwork.

Phildickian Rule by replacing reality with an abstract, ersatz virtual image of it. This technique of social control began with literacy*—and the creation of written symbols, which devalued soft conscious sensuous inspiration, fostered a private (reader-text) interaction with society, created the illusion that language is a thing, that meaning can be stored, owned and perfectly duplicated, that elite-language is standard and so on—and ended with virtuality—the conversion of classrooms, offices, prisons, shops and similar social spaces into ‘immersive’ on-line holodecks which control and reward participants through permanent, perfect surveillance, the stimulation of positive and negative emotion, offers of godlike powers, and threats to nonconformists of either narco-withdrawal or banishment to an off-line reality now so degraded by the demands of manufacturing an entire artificial universe, that only hellish production-facilities, shoddy living-units and prisons can materially function there.

The reader can decide for herself under which of above we currently struggle to eke out a life worth living. I would like to suggest that all modern societies are both Kafkaesque and Phildickian with either a Huxleyan or Orwellian overarching framework; modern, western, capitalist societies tend to be basically Huxleyan (HKP) and pre-modern, eastern, communist countries tend to be basically Orwellian (OKP).

The reason why ideological managers** (academics, film directors, journalists, etc) prefer to have two (or more) dystopian systems is that it makes us seem like the goodies and them the baddies. Communism is to blame for their foodbanks and breadlines, but capitalism has nothing to do with ours (or vice versa). Sure our masses have the same miserable lives as theirs, reel under the same bureaucratic insanity, stumble around the same shoddy unreal worlds, and witness the same catastrophic destruction of nature and beauty as theirs do, but at least we’ve got democracy! / at least our families stick together! / at least the trains run on time! / at least GTA 9 is coming out soon / at least the Olympics will cheer us up (delete as appropriate).

 

This is an adapted extract from The Apocalypedia.

 

* Obviously I’m not suggesting that literacy is inherently or completely dystopian, but it is the beginning of a dangerous and distorting process, which starts with societies demanding literacy for participation — and devaluing orality and improvised forms of expression — and ends with the complete eradication of reality. This danger and distortion increases with every step towards virtuality (print, perspective, photography, television, internet) until, by the time we reach VR, there remains no possibility of reverie, transcendence, humanity, meaning or genuine creativity, all of which become suspect.

** And of course for those who depend on their illusions.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Authoritarianism, consciousness, culture, Dystopia, media, Philosophy, propaganda, Psy-ops, Social Control, Social Engineering, society, State Crime, surveillance state and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Four Kinds of Dystopia

  1. ebolainfo says:

    We need to create visual alternatives to these dystopic visions. What films, books show the utopian alternatives?

    • Perhaps a reason there’s far more media depictions of dystopia than utopia (besides utopia being less inherently dramatic) is that we’re more certain about what a society shouldn’t be than what it should be. That being said, a great example if utopia can be found in the Star Trek episode “This Side of Paradise”, though it also depicts why such societies are unlikely to last very long.

      • ebolainfo says:

        I agree it is easier to reject/react to what you do not like however we must start fleshing out alternative visions.
        Some of Jon Rappoport’s articles hint at this…the joy, energy acttivated when your being is aligned with a vision, an idea.
        Entrepreneurs are obvious examples of that energised drive to realise an idea.
        That is the challenge for truthers! What empowering visions of utopia can we engender in our fellows.
        I would love to see films exploring various visions/ideas of human societies in contrast to globalist/criminal dystopias.
        The society/community as the hero. What journey must it undergoe to reach the ideal destination? What hardships must the “hero” overcome?

  2. Pingback: Four Types of Dystopia | TroyGrice.com

  3. Pingback: Four Types of Dystopia | TroyGrice.com

  4. sojourner says:

    Reblogged this on An Outsider's Sojourn II.

  5. Troy says:

    Reblogging this. Thank you.

  6. Franz Kafka-I thought I was the only one in literature class appreciated the nuanced allegorical nature of his stories. Well done!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

3rd Shelf

Everything at Eye Level

Russia Photos

"Russia Photos" is a blog run by Alex Markovich. MarkovichUniverse AT gmail DOT com

soul factory

a blog experiment

tagoreanworld

World Change as conceived by Rabindranath Tagore

The Friday Room

A pluralist politics forum for progressives

mawrgorshin

Mind-expanding writing.

%d bloggers like this: